Crotty's Cheesesteaks

Guillaume Chazenfus a month ago

After seeing a recent review on social media, my wife and I decided to order for pick up and eat it in the car just outside the place. Honestly one of the top 3 cheesesteaks I've ever had. Great flavor! You can tell the ingredients are quality. My wife tried the Cooper sharp and I had the cheese wiz. Normally the wiz kinda grosses me out, but honestly this one was the perfect consistency and since ai hear they make their own I had to give it a go. Will be my ho to here. Also important to note, the time estimate when we placed the order was spot on. Also the staff are friendly. Overall great experience and will definitely be getting this again.

Xuam Lau a month ago

I have to be honest I was first a bit bias thinking it was a spot for college kids and they didn't know about food because they eat what they can. Anyway I went in yesterday for lunch it was hot like I stepped into a sauna, but I got a Paulie and mozzarella sticks man all I can say bruh that cheese steak was so so so good. I'll definitely go back and try other sandwiches. I didn't get any napkins on the way out so I didn't give higher stars for the service but other than that it was good and the atmosphere and 1000° degrees that's why I have it a two stars. Definitely check out it you won't be sorry.

CJ Cremeans a month ago

Crotty’s cheesesteaks were nothing short of amazing! I went to college in Philly so I’ve been to all the spots. Crotty’s can hang with all of them. Great variety and great service. Even the fries are good. Highly recommended!

Richie Quiñones a year ago

Thoroughly enjoyed this spot. We finally came in after following for years on social media when I believe the owners would be delivering food to locals throughout Westchester during the pandemic. So let’s get down to it, my family and I came in right around 4 o’clock on a Saturday afternoon. We know it’s a college spot so we didn’t want to risk going during a lunch or dinner rush. When we walked in we were the only ones there and were quickly greeted by a young gentleman and a woman in the kitchen area. Our order: 1 order of chicken fingers & fries 1 mac & cheesesteak bowl. 1 traditional sandwich (shortie size) and 1 Chopped Chicken Parm Philly (New Item) I had originally asked for the Rocky Cheesesteak but since it had mozzarella and marinara sauce the young man took notice and recommended their new Chicken Parm Philly. As a chicken parm fan, I couldn’t say “no” Our order was in and I took some pictures of the shop. It’s clean, bright, tidy and printed menus are available along with a poster board on the left side wall with their full menu. I’ve seen interior picture of the location from before and it looks like the new color scheme and dripping cheese theme were put up rece

John H 4 years ago

Step aside Philly, there's a new sheriff in town. I've had all the heavy hitters before. I've taken a a road trip just for a sandwich from Pat's or Genos. Now there's Crottys. This is the perfect spot in Westchester for anything craveable, hearty and cheesy. As soon as you walk in, youre going to see the menu stacked with insane combinations. They don't just have guilty pleasures either. They have tons of gluten free, vegetarian and vegan options. The staff gives you a warm and inviting greeting when you walk in and have the grill fired up and ready to go. I ordered the Nacho cheesesteak, chicken fingers, Mac n cheese, and the cheesecake bites. I could sit here all day and tell you how great everything was. The leftovers didn't even make it on the car ride home. This sandwich was STACKED with a pound of meat, flaming hot Doritos, ooey gooey cheese, onions, jalapeños and all the fixins. Need I say more?!?! The chicken fingers were crispy and perfectly partnered with Buffalo sauce and their signature slaw. The mac n cheese was sooooo cheesy! Thank you so much Joe, Lindsay, and Paul. Every experience gets better than the last!